The live-action adaptation of “One Piece” has achieved remarkable success, boasting the highest ratings among Hollywood’s attempts to bring anime to life.
It’s also become the most-watched Netflix show in over 80 countries. However, this viewership primarily consists of existing fans, which raises questions about the show’s broader appeal.
Eiichiro Oda, the creator of “One Piece,” envisioned the series as a global phenomenon that would transcend cultural boundaries. With themes of friendship, determination, and the pursuit of dreams, Oda saw the live-action adaptation as a final opportunity to make “One Piece” a worldwide sensation.
While the live-action series has been a hit among existing fans, it hasn’t broken out of the “One Piece” bubble (yet). Despite high ratings on platforms like Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb, these accolades come mostly from viewers already familiar with the franchise. Newcomers often offer lukewarm or negative reviews.
For instance, one IMDb reviewer who had never watched the anime or read the manga commented, “I don’t like Anime, never have, especially this older stuff. Never watched one piece the cartoon or know anything about it. After first two episodes I’m just fine never having heard of this or watched it.
This is silly kids stuff. I guess this is fine if your a fan of the original but someone like me that just comes in cold to watch this is not interested real quick. I’m guessing the fans will give it huge reviews and make everyone knows it has high reviews. My guess is after the hype dies down no one will care or watch it again.”
Also Read: Uncle Roger’s One Piece Food Review Video Gets Copyright Claimed By Toei Studio
For those unfamiliar with anime and manga, the live-action adaptation falls short of capturing the unique charm and energy that define the original series, making it a less-than-ideal introduction to the world of “One Piece.”
While it serves as decent fan service, faithfully recreating key moments and characters, it often feels like a checklist of plot points rather than a reimagined narrative that could attract a new audience.
Although it’s crucial to honor the source material, a successful adaptation should also inject new life into the story to make it accessible to a broader audience. Unfortunately, the Netflix series fails to present “One Piece’s” timeless themes in a universally compelling manner.
Ultimately, the live-action “One Piece” has won existing fans’ hearts, but it falls short of fulfilling Oda’s dream of captivating a global audience.
Only time will tell if the live-action adaptation can truly spread Eiichiro Oda’s already popular series to a worldwide audience. Perhaps, with another chance, Luffy and the Straw Hats can truly set sail for worldwide acclaim.
Read More: What do Japanese Fans Think of One Piece Live Action Series?
Source: IMDb
